Lloyd Fredendall: One of the Most Unsuccessful American Generals of WWII

Photo Credit: 1. PhotoQuest / Getty Images 2. MPI / Getty Images

The military is an institution built on order and service. While the majority who join abide by these values, others choose to disregard the chain of command, resulting in disastrous consequences. This is true of Lloyd Fredendall, whose actions hurt Allied operations following the landings in North Africa.

Lloyd Fredendall’s military beginnings

Lloyd Fredendall was born on Fort D.A. Russell near Cheyenne, Wyoming on December 28, 1883. His father served in the Quartermaster Corps during the Spanish-American War and remained active in the military until his retirement in 1914. He reenlisted during World War I to supervise the construction of bases in the western United States, and retired at the end of the conflict having reached the rank of lieutenant colonel.

His father’s connections enabled Frenendall to secure a recommendation from Senator Francis E. Warren to enter the class of 1905 at the United States Military Academy. He was dismissed after one semester. He was allowed to rejoin, but dropped out. While Sen. Warren was willing to appoint him a third time, USMA refused to re-admit Frendendall.

Lloyd Fredendall in military uniform
Fredendall, February 1943. (Photo Credit: PhotoQuest / Getty Images)

In 1906, he took the officer’s qualifying exam and scored first out of 70 applicants. A year later, on February 13, 1907, he received his commission in the US Army as a second lieutenant in the Infantry Branch.

Service during World War I and peacetime

After serving in the Philippines and in other assignments, Fredendall was sent to the Western Front with the 28th Infantry Regiment. He instructed at the Army’s schools in France, where he built a reputation as an excellent teacher and trainer.

When the war came to an end, he was assigned to training duties. He was both a student and an instructor at the US Army Infantry School, and in 1923 graduated from the US Army Command and General Staff School. He further increased his status within the Army upon graduating from the US Army War College in 1925.

Lloyd Fredendall walking in front of a line of British soldiers
Fredendall, January 1943. (Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons)

Fredendall also completed multiple tours of duty in Washington at the Statistics Branch, the Inspector General’s Department and as executive officer at the Office of the Chief of the Infantry.

Operation Torch and the Allied invasion of North Africa

Lloyd Fredendall was promoted to brigadier general in December 1939 and given command of the 5th Infantry Division. A year later, he was promoted to major general and given command of the 4th Infantry Division until July 1941.

In preparation of the Allied Invasion of North Africa – known as Operation TorchGeneral Dwight D. Eisenhower, the Supreme Allied Commander in North Africa, chose Fredendall to command the 39,000-strong Central Task Force. Once there, he was assigned command of the US II Corps in its advance into Tunisia.

Rear Admiral A.C. Bennett, General Alain de Boissieu, Major-General Lloyd Fredendall and Admiral André Georges Rioult looking at documents on a table
Generals in North Africa: Rear Admiral A.C. Bennett, General Alain de Boissieu, Major-General Lloyd Fredendall and Admiral André Georges Rioult. (Photo Credit: Hulton Archive / Getty Images)

At the time, the II Corps served under the British First Army, commanded by Lieutenant General Kenneth A.N. Anderson. Anderson found Fredendall to be incompetent, as he used slang when addressing troops and made up confusing codes, instead of using the standard military map grid-based location designators.

Allied advance on Tunisia

In January 1943, the German and Italian troops of Panzerarmee Afrika, under the command of General Erwin Rommel, had retreated 1,400 miles westward into Tunisia. Bulked up by reinforcements, a force of 30 panzers broke through at Faid Pass on January 30 and struck the French positions stationed there.

The French reached out to the American forces for help, but the unit was too small and failed to push back the Germans. During this, Fredendall remained 70 miles away, overseeing the construction of the II Corps headquarters by a company from the 19th Engineer Regiment.

British troops and tanks climbing a hill
British soldiers with the 2nd Battalion, Grenadier Guards, establishing positions at Thala, February 24, 1943. (Photo Credit: No 2 Army Film & Photographic Unit / Wikimedia Commons)

Obsessed with the possibility of an air attack from the Germans, Fredendall constructed underground bunkers and anti-aircraft guns. Brigadier General Omar Bradley called the headquarters “an embarrassment to every American soldier,” while General Eisenhower used it as an opportunity to remind senior officers of the importance of appearing on the front.

Fredendall refused to heed Eisenhower’s orders and remained at II Corps headquarters. He rarely visited the front lines, opting to issue orders over the radio, and disregarded advice from those on the front. As such, he split up units and scattered them too far apart to support each other or be effective. This left them vulnerable to an attack by Axis forces.

Panic at the Battle of Sidi Bou Zid

On February 14, 1943, the Germans launched an offensive at Sidi Bou Zid. Fredendall refused to move from his position at II Corps Headquarters. His hilltop defensive positions at Djebel Lessouda and Djebel Ksaira were too far apart to provide mutual support, meaning the Americans could only sit back and watch the German onslaught.

American soldiers walking around a damaged German tank
American soldiers looking over a damaged German tank, February 1943. (Photo Credit: MPI / Getty Images)

A counterattack was launched the next day but failed. As such, the Americans abandoned Sidi Bou Zid but were cut off at Djebel Lessouda and Djebel Ksaira. The result was a mass panic while the Germans launched Junkers Ju-87 attacks.

Of the 900 men sent into battle, only 300 returned. Demoralized by the defeat and pushed back 50 miles, the Americans fell back to the Kasserine Pass, providing the Germans a pathway through which they could break through Allied rear areas.

The Battle of Kasserine Pass reveals Fredendall’s incompetence

The Battle of Kasserine Pass occurred from February 19 to 24, 1943. After heavy fighting, the Germans broke through the pass, but the arrival of Allied reinforcements, paired with issues within the German command, stopped the assault. In just 10 days, the Americans lost 183 tanks and 7,000 troops, of which 300 were killed and another 3,000 listed as missing.

M3 Lee tank driving toward a cactus in the desert
M3 Lee tank advancing to support American forces at the Battle of Kasserine Pass. (Photo Credit: WWII Signal Corps Photograph Collection / Wikimedia Commons)

Eisenhower sent Major General Ernest N. Harmon of the 2nd Armored Division to report on the fighting. He was also tasked with assisting the Allied commanders, including Fredendall, and determining whether he or his 1st Armored Division commander, Major General Orlando Ward, should be replaced.

He learnt Fredendall and Anderson rarely saw each other and failed to coordinate those forces under their command. Harmon also found out he wasn’t on speaking terms with Maj. Gen. Ward, whom he intentionally left out of operational meetings after the pair had a difference of opinion regarding the distribution of his command.

While interviewing field commanders and troops, Harmon discovered Ferdendall was doling out commands contrary to Anderson, causing confusion on the front, and that positions were such that units couldn’t support each other. The field commanders, in particular, felt Fredendall was out-of-touch and a cowardly leader.

Military portrait of Dwight D. Eisenhower
Dwight D. Eisenhower, December 1943. (Photo Credit: US Army / Wikimedia Commons)

Concerned, Harmon requested permission to go to the front and shore up Allied defenses.

Fredendall is replaced by Patton

Following the events at Kasserine Pass, Eisenhower visited II Corps headquarters to confer with Brig. Gen. Bradley, who’d spoken with division commanders and received the same responses as Harmon. It was then the decision was made to replace Fredendall.

While 18th Army Group commander British General Sir Harold R.L.G. Alexander informed Eisenhower he would happily take Fredendall’s place, Eisenhower approached Harmon, who declined, citing it would be unethical to appear to personally benefit from his assessment of Fredendall.

George Patton in military uniform
George Patton, 1943. (Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons)

In the end, control of the II Corps was given to Major General George Patton, who assumed the position on March 6, 1943. Under his command, the unit was transformed, as he implemented a strict uniform policy and training regiment. The turnaround resulted in a morale-boosting victory at El Guettar, just 10 days after.

Due to the events of the Battle of Kasserine Pass, Fedendall went down in history as one of the most unsuccessful generals of the Second World War. While not completely to blame for the Allied failure, as American troops were largely green and overconfident, his inability to follow command structure and his withholding of information are largely to blame.

Closing years of World War II

Lloyd Fredendall returned to the US at Eisenhower’s recommendation. Despite his mistakes, Eisenhower’s refusal to formally reprimand allowed him to be promoted to lieutenant general and eligible for three-star assignments, which he duly received. He returned to the US with a hero’s welcome.

Eisenhower’s aide made a report to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, where it was communicated, without elaboration, that Eisenhower wished for Fredendall to be reassigned to a training command. This recommendation was followed and Fredenall spent the remainder of the war working training assignments across the US.

Lloyd Fredendall sitting at a table while looking over documents
Fredendall, 1943. (Photo Credit: PhotoQuest / Getty Images)

Fredendall continued to serve in the US Army through to the end of the war. He retired on March 31, 1946.